Wireless TV services given free rein by CRTC. Industry cheers decision not to regulate

by Catherine McLean
The Globe and Mail
April 3, 2006


Cellphone TV services started with hockey clips and news but now the broadcasting regulator has given wireless carriers carte blanche to move beyond traditional television.

Mobile TV services from Telus Corp., Bell Mobility Inc. and Rogers Wireless Communications Inc. are delivered over the Internet and aren't subject to the same rules as those provided by cable operators and broadcasters, the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission said yesterday.

Cellphone carriers should be able to experiment in the TV sector without immediately dealing with regulatory restrictions, CRTC chairman Charles Dalfen said. Unlike other TV distributors, for example, mobile TV services won't be required to carry specific channels.

It's early days for this emerging technology as Canadian wireless carriers only launched their TV services last year. Observers say only a fraction of cellphone customers subscribe to such services.

"It's too early stage to want to clamp a regulatory regime on it," Mr. Dalfen said in an interview, adding that's a possibility in the future if it has a big impact on the TV sector. "At this stage, it's not even clear what a mobile program is."

Wireless companies welcomed the decision. "It's going to continue to allow the very experimentation around content delivery that the commission was trying to accomplish in its new-media exemption order" said Janet Yale, executive vice-president of government and regulatory affairs at Vancouver-based Telus.

In effect, the CRTC reaffirmed a position it took in 1999 with its new-media exemption order in which it would not set rules for broadcasting services over the Net.

Other TV industry participants, however, had sought another outcome. The Canadian Association of Broadcasters (CAB) submitted several proposals to the CRTC, including one that would have required that mobile TV services to be owned by Canadians and another that would have required them to contribute to Canadian talent development funds.

The CAB did not immediately comment yesterday.

"It is likely that the commission will catch some flak on this from the old-school contingent," said Kaan Yigit, president of Solutions Research Group. "That's unavoidable to the extent that every new technology is threatening one established order or the other."

However, networks have no choice but to adapt as TV starts to take off on wireless phones, computers and other devices. This week, Walt Disney Co.'s ABC network unveiled a two-month trial to offer U.S. viewers four of its most popular shows on the Internet.

Wireless TV offers opportunities for major networks, such as Global, CTV or CBC, Mr. Yigit believes. "In fact, there could be very interesting cross-platform possibilities, whether in the form of short bits promoting main TV properties or highlights packages or even testing new ideas in short-form first."

Mobile TV is a "niche" for customers who want sports or news updates on the run and it won't replace cable, said Ken Engelhart, vice-president of regulatory affairs at Rogers Communications Inc., which owns Rogers Wireless.

"People who are worried this is going to affect the Canadian broadcasting business, they're like Chicken Little," Mr. Engelhart said.

The selection of channels on wireless TV -- 20 at most -- is much smaller than that offeredon cable. Depending on the carrier, subscribers can watch The Shopping Channel, CBC Newsworld, MuchMusic or YTV.

New content will likely develop for wireless TV because people won't want to watch 30-minute sitcoms on the small screen, observers say. Clips of sporting events or stories that last a few minutes will be popular, predicts Yankee Group analyst Jeff Leiper.

But others have concerns about the content on wireless TV.

In a statement yesterday, the Alliance of Canadian Cinema, Television and Radio Artists said it's concerned about more U.S. programming, and argued that wireless TV broadcasters should contribute to the production of Canadian programs.



To the top